The Buyer’s Guide to the Best Nursing Pillow

The Buyer’s Guide To The Best Nursing Pillow

When you’re a parent, there’s not much that you won’t do for your children. As a parent of a new baby, you’re especially aware of everything they need and will stop at nothing to make sure they feel safe, comfortable, and supportive.

Breastfeeding is one of the biggest parts of becoming a new mother and something that takes hours out of your day, particularly in the newborn months. Even though we do so much for our babies, making sure we also feel comfortable and supported while we do this very important job is something that is often overlooked.

Baby In Nursing Pillow

If you have a baby on the way or know somebody who is expecting, there’s a good chance you’ve already started your search for the best nursing pillow. Perhaps you’ve been reading the best nursing pillow reviews or comparing the top brands to see which one will be the right choice.

With something so important as this accessory, for both mother and baby, you really want to make sure you’re getting the best pillow possible. That’s why we’ve compiled this simple buying guide to walk you through our top picks for the best friend nursing pillow you could ever ask for and how to find one with features that suit what you’re after.

Product Name

Our Rating

Best Nursing Pillows For Nursing Gliders

Best Nursing Pillows For Football Hold

Best Nursing Pillow For Twins

What Is a Nursing Pillow?

If you are a new mom or you are new to breastfeeding, then you may not know what a nursing pillow is and how it can help you. As a mom, there are going to be a lot of things you will have to practice and get used to until you get into a routine and rhythm that works best for you. Nursing is just one of those things that may take some time to master.

A nursing pillow helps get baby in a good position for nursing that is comfortable for both of you. The pillow helps when it comes time to prop the baby up for breastfeeding and takes some of the weight off your arms by supporting the baby. Even the smallest baby can become quite heavy to hold in the same position for a long time.

The nursing pillow can sit nicely on your lap and often wraps around the body for the best support. It is a stable and comfortable position for the baby and helps reduce your risk of any neck, arm, and back strain as you breastfeed your newborn.

Do I Have to Use a Nursing Pillow?

You don't have to use a nursing pillow, but it is a more effective way of supporting yourself, and the baby while nursing and works much more efficiently when compared to using a regular pillow. The special design makes a nursing pillow much more effective. Even if you aren't breastfeeding your baby, it is also extremely useful for supporting yourself, and the baby as you bottle feed as well. Nursing pillows are not just limited to nursing mothers.

In addition to feeding time, as your child grows older, the nursing pillow can also be used for tummy time or to cradle your baby before they can sit up on their own. When used for tummy time, it lifts the baby and allows them to have a much better view and allows them to interact with their toys a bit more.

Our Picks for the Best Nursing Pillow

Nursing pillows haven’t always been around, but for the last 20 years or so they’ve become something that new mothers have relied on. Aimed to support women as they breastfeed to make it easier and more natural, as well as give baby somewhere comfortable to rest as they feed, they’re an essential piece of baby gear.

With so many on the market, we’ve done the hard work to recommend nursing pillows to suit all kinds of mothers and babies.

Best Nursing Pillows for Nursing Gliders

Having a nursing glider can be a lifesaver in the first few months, but you’ll need a nursing pillow to fit with the chair. These are our top picks for glider suitable pillows, but those that could also be the best pillow for nursing in bed, the couch, or anywhere you feel most comfortable.

Winner: My Brest Friend Nursing Pillow

A good nursing pillow should be up to the task no matter where you’re sitting and in need of a feed, and the My Brest Friend Nursing Pillow ticks all of the boxes.

This is our top pick for one that would suit a nursing glider, but because it’s so versatile, you can use it wherever you want around the home or anywhere else.

My Brest Friend has been making these accessories for over 20 years, and they’re considered one of the top pillows, but with that premium status comes a price that’s about twice as much as the competition.

Considering the thousands of happy moms who’ve used them and commented on their quality, it seems they’re worth the higher cost.

my brest friend nursing pillow

This pillow is unique in how it feels to others, and you’ll find that it’s quite firm. The pillow was designed this way to keep baby safe and prevent them from moving around too much and ensuring that they’re never in a dangerous position.

However, if you need something softer or are perhaps looking for the best nursing pillow for c-section incision recovery, you may want it a little more luxurious.

What makes this such a great product is the high quality, but also how easy it is to keep clean. You’ll be able to remove the cover and throw it in the wash, and it has a convenient pouch for storing things that you might want in arm’s reach while you’re nursing. These little features are really appreciated when you’re stuck in your glider feeding for hours, so you’ll certainly love them.

There are 18 colors and designs to choose from, and plenty of vibrant looks for those who want something dramatic. My Brest Friend has also added an adjustable strap that helps you secure the pillow around your waist so that it won’t shift around. As a common complaint with other similar products, it’s good to see that one brand was taking notice of this annoyance.

If you can afford to spend a little more this 100% cotton nursing pillow is definitely the best choice for use with a glider. Provided you’re happy with a firmer than usual pillow, there’s really nothing else negative to note about the My Brest Friend Nursing Pillow, and it’s obvious why they’ve been a market leader for so many years.

OUR RATING


Runner-Up: Boppy Newborn Lounger

One thing that parents miss when they have a baby is how little hands-free time they get.

The Boppy Newborn Lounger aims to solve this problem and gives mom great breastfeeding support with the comfortable and supportive nest designed for the smallest of babies.

Boppy is a name synonymous with breastfeeding pillows and were one of the first to ever break into the market.

Every little design feature they include on a Boppy pillow shows why they’re so popular, and their amazing price puts them well below other respected brands on the market.

Boppy Newborn Lounger

This is the best travel nursing pillow when you’re not resting in your nursing glider as it has a convenient handle on the side. It’s lightweight so you can pick it up and take it anywhere, even traveling with it on the plane. This minor addition to the pillow will come in handy as you move around the house or go out in the car, so it definitely sets the Boppy apart.

Some customers commented that the size could have been a bit larger, for both baby and mom. If you’re on the smaller side and have been searching for the best nursing pillow for petite moms, then this news will probably be a positive for you, but those on the larger side might want to keep shopping.

The Boppy Newborn Lounger was only really designed for newborn months, and once they’re over 16 pounds they won’t be able to fit comfortably. So, while the Boppy is a great price and you’ll certainly get a lot of use out of it, don’t expect that you’ll be nursing with it for your entire breastfeeding journey unless you can figure out a better comfortable position that it still works in.

In terms of cleaning, the Boppy was made with a soft, wipeable fabric so you should be able to remove most stains with a simple cloth. When you do need a deeper clean, you can put the entire thing into the washing machine, but just be careful you don’t end up with anything too lumpy.

For the price, you really won’t find anything of this quality and by a brand as renowned as respected as Boppy. This is a multifunctional pillow that’s somewhere for baby to relax and a breastfeeding support accessory, so for a product that can truly do it all, you should invest in the Boppy Newborn Glider.

OUR RATING


Alternative: Leachco Cuddle-U Nursing Pillow

Not only is it a comfortable and supportive place for baby to rest while they feed, keeping mom comfortable and in a relaxed position, but it also acts as a digestive support pillow so that their milk stays down and they avoid common newborn issues like acid reflux.

leachco cuddle u nursing pillow

This is a truly multipurpose pillow because you can also use it when they’re not feeding. It has a special U-shape design and a safety wrap so your baby can sit in comfortably and play, even through the months they’re learning to do so on their own. In terms of value for money, this one has the others beat because you’ll truly use it for at least for the first year of their life.

The main problem with this pillow comes with cleaning as it doesn’t come with a replacement pillow cover and they’re quite hard to find. Some mothers have commented that they had to sew their own, which is a major annoyance. Before buying, you’ll want to make sure you can find a pillow cover, an extra removable cover, or have some other method (like burp rags) for keeping it free from milk and the other stains that happen with a new baby.

According to the reviews, this is a great choice for the best nursing pillow after a C-section incision because it’s incredibly soft and fluffy. Some might feel uncomfortable without a firm base for feeding their baby, so be aware before you purchase it that this isn’t one of those. The Cuddle-U nursing pillow is extremely soft and cuddly, and there isn’t much in terms of firmness here.

The Cuddle-U Nursing Pillow is a great price for everything that it can do, and because of the soft flexibility of its design, it’s perfect for nursing gliders. You’ll be able to get it right around you and baby and rest comfortably while you breastfeed, so it has plenty of notable features that make it a great choice for new mothers.

OUR RATING


Best Nursing Pillows for Football Hold

Itzy Ritzy Milk Boss

When you’re learning how to breastfeed, you’ll usually have a favorite position that works for you and baby, and for most breastfeeding moms, this is the football hold.

For those who favor this simple and effective nursing position, you’ll want a nursing pillow to suit, and the Itzy Ritzy Milk Boss is our top recommendation.

Where the Milk Boss differs is that it’s made for all types of feeding, so it doesn’t matter if mom is nursing or dad is giving a bottle, the custom design will suit.

It features a special shape that takes the pressure and strains off your arm and gives you somewhere to rest, so there’s no need to feel uncomfortable.

Itzy Ritzy Milk Boss

Because it’s so easy to use, you could also let your other kids have a turn feeding the baby and feel totally safe about it. Don’t buy this pillow expecting it to be full-sized like others as it’s more about just supporting your arm.

If you want something just for the football hold and not really adjustable to other positions though, you can save a lot of money by going with the more compact option that the Milk Boss offers.

One notable feature that the Milk Boss has over others is the inner lining that keeps it cool. This means it’s perfect for the warmer months or climates that don’t need a lot of extra heat. With other nursing pillows featuring a thick liner, you can get hot easily, and baby can too, so this feature is definitely worth mentioning and a huge plus for Itzy Ritzy.

When it comes to cleaning, the whole pillow can be placed into the wash, or you can spot clean problem areas with a simple wet cloth. Because it’s smaller in size it actually fits better in the machine and the materials, and inner fill are durable enough to withstand a regular wash cycle.

Customers were pretty thrilled at how well this supported them during the football hold, and it was great for other caregivers too. If you want something more compact and useful for specific positions while feeding, the Itzy Ritzy Milk Boss Nursing Pillow could be the answer to your prayers.

OUR RATING


Best Nursing Pillow for Twins

My Brest Friend Nursing Pillow for Twins

Finding the best twin nursing pillow requires a different set of features, thanks to the very special circumstances that two little babies make.

Regular nursing pillows aren’t really designed to hold two babies comfortably as they nurse, but the My Brest Friend Nursing Pillow for Twins certainly is.

My Brest Friend is a leader when it comes to nursing pillows, and they’ve truly thought of every baby and mother when they designed their range.

This special twin nursing pillow suits babies aged 0-12 months until they’re big enough to nurse without a pillow, and there’s ample space for two hungry babies to rest.

my-brest-friend-nursing-pillow-twins

The large u-shaped design of this pillow means you can do tandem nursing, or even just one at a time should the need ever arise. There’s enough space and plenty of comfort, and both of your babies will be firmly supported and relaxing on a 100% polyester cover.

With a shape that wraps around mom’s entire body, you have plenty of options for how you can feed your little ones. However, judging by some of the reviews, breastfeeding moms found that there were times that it didn’t feel as though it was close enough to their bodies. There was a slight gap that they had to keep adjusting every few minutes, which is pretty annoying when you have your mind on feeding.

This is a lot longer and wider than other twin pillows, so you don’t have to worry about them growing out of it too soon, and when you consider how much use you’ll get out of it, the price seems even more reasonable. Because of the special design, it’s even possible to bottle feed your babies both on this pillow, so other caregivers can have a turn as well.

There are plenty of notable features on the My Brest Friend Twin Nursing Pillow. With a convenient pocket for keeping your supplies close by, a matte finish that makes it glare-free and washable, and plenty of cool colors and designs to choose from, it’s more than just a support accessory.

This pillow is stylish, practical, and especially helpful for mothers who have their hands full with two brand new babies.

My Brest Friend is a trusted name and a top choice for many lactation consultants and hospitals, so you know you’re getting something good. They may be a little more expensive than the competition, but if you want the absolute best and need to ensure a smooth nursing journey for you and your twins, you won’t mind paying a little extra.

OUR RATING


The Best Nursing Pillow for Portability

The Nursie Slip-On Arm Nursing Pillow

If you are looking for a much more portable option that still allows you to achieve the best possible nursing position and good latch, then the Nursie Slip-On Arm Nursing Pillow is the ideal pick for you and baby.

It gently wraps around mom's arm and has a very similar design of arm floaties your older children might use while in the pool. It provides a snug fit around mom's arm, and there is no need for any kind of straps to keep it in place.

It is versatile and can be used for whatever nursing position you and baby are the most comfortable with. If you find yourself away from the home a lot, you will quickly find that this nursing pillow is small and compact enough to fit nicely into your diaper bag or even a carry-on bag if you are doing any traveling.

The Nursie is also machine washable, which is always a plus when it is being used with baby. With this nursing pillow, you can prop baby up while feeding to ultimately reduce acid reflux and allow you to achieve the best position while nursing and holding the baby to avoid any strain or pain.

the nursie slip on arm nursing pillow

This is one of the best and most portable choices for any new parent. It has a very simple design, and it is easy to use. You don't have to fight with any straps or Velcro which is especially important when your baby is howling for their meal.

The Nursie helps cut down on some of the frustration new moms feel as they get used to feeding their little ones. If the baby has some excited siblings that are eager to hold the newest addition, then this is also the perfect way to accomplish that while making sure the baby's head and neck are fully supported.

The Features to Look for in a Nursing Pillow

Whether you’re a new parent or you’re just new to using nursing pillows, trying to navigate your way around all of the different options can be overwhelming. It’s hard to know what features really matter and those that are just there for show.

These are some of the features you’ll find on a standard nursing pillow and what they mean for the overall comfort, support, and practicality they offer.

Material

Nursing Pillow Form

There are two key areas to look at when considering the material of a nursing pillow. First is the inner lining of foam that’s used for comfort and firmness, and secondly is the cover or outer material.

You want something that’s machine washable, easy to clean, and with the right amount of support. Some moms prefer a firm feel, and others want softness, and it’s totally a personal choice with no right or wrong answer.

Support

The support a pillow offers is important for both mother and baby. For the mom, you need adequate support to take the strain off your arms, neck, and back. For the baby, there should be adequate support for their head and neck, and somewhere for the rest of them to lay. Some pillows are multifunctional and also allow for the baby to sit, lay, or digest in the correct position.

Size

Check the measurements of the pillow before deciding on the final one. Some are larger, wider, or longer, and others are designed for compact use. The size will also determine how long the baby will fit on it so if you’re after value for money, then look for a pillow that lasts up to 12 months or further.

Type Of Pillow

There are different types of nursing pillows that suit specific families and scenarios. Travel pillows, position-specific pillows, tandem or twin pillows, and those designed for bottle feeding and breastfeeding.

Weight

The weight of the pillow is important for those who plan on traveling with it. A heavy pillow could mean a firmer one, but not always. Lightweight pillows are easier to transport and generally fit in more situations, like laying down or while using a nursing glider. Some might also come with a carry handle if you plan on traveling as well.

Ease Of Use

There are various designs which dictate the ease of use a pillow has, and each mother will have their own preference. You can choose armrest pillows, ones that wrap around the body completely, those with a buckle and strap, or something simple that goes up front for the baby to lay on. Depending on the adjustability and style you want, you’ll need to shop for those specific features.

The Perfect Accessory for Mom and Baby

Baby On Nursing Pillow

Babies, unfortunately, don’t come with a manual on how to care for them correctly, but if they did, you can guarantee that a nursing pillow would be part of the essentials checklist.

These amazing accessories have helped so many moms and other caregivers to feed their babies and take some of the usual stress out of the first year of life.

New motherhood can be a challenging time, whether it’s your first baby or your fifth. Having something as simple and supportive as the best nursing pillow by your side makes it a whole lot easier but choosing the right one will make all the difference.

To make life even easier, when choosing the nursing pillow for you, make sure it is machine washable or has a removable cover to make it easy to clean up those mishaps and accidents during feeding time. Nursing moms should also read as many pillow reviews as possible to get a better idea about what other moms who have used these products are saying.

Nursing pillows come in all shapes and sizes, and we’re lucky to have so many great options out there today. Finding the best nursing pillow for mother and baby may take some time, but it’s an investment that will pay off greatly when it comes to caring for your bundle of joy.

Leave a Comment: